Edinbox
A Great Woman Can Never Be a Great Daughter: Why?

A Great Woman Can Never Be a Great Daughter

Schools, colleges, universities, MNC’s, everywhere the percentage of women is increasing but the people holding the top spots are still men. And no, it’s not that women are any less, it’s just that they are trying to balance being an ambitious soul and being a great daughter, mother, wife, and lady of the house. Because if they aren’t, they become a high achieving, great woman but also a “bad influence on daughters”.

It has been a strange paradox that although Indian society encourages daughters to dream, be educated, have a career and become self-sufficient individuals, they also make them aware that they shouldn’t sacrifice being a good daughter. Whilst women may have leadership positions, be financially independent, make important decisions and receive recognition, they are often questioned about their decisions to not go through with a marriage, have a different career, talk to relatives more often, or simply want to live life on their own terms. It seems that becoming a successful woman is acceptable as long as they continue to be a good daughter.

That’s why the comment ‘A great woman can never be a great daughter’ causes discomfort. It’s not that women can’t love their parents if they are ambitious, but society have created the idea that a great daughter is very specific. Women who wish to be independent can easily not fit their criteria. The issue isn’t that women are becoming less loving daughters, it’s the fact that their love is being measured by how much they conform, sacrifice and put others first.

What Makes a Great Daughter?

When asking people what makes a great daughter, you’ll receive similar answers. They will take care of their parents, understand their struggles, respect their decisions, listen without arguing and never make them feel like their sacrifices aren’t appreciated. They will be good at studying, have a respectable career but won’t let their ambitions consume them to the point they forget about their family. They will get married at the correct age, ideally when their parents have found them a suitable partner and won’t question their decisions too much. Once married they will still look after their parents, keep relationships with their family and meet their obligations with their new family.

Whilst looking after your parents, respecting their opinions and getting married isn’t bad, the issue is that society have created them as requirements to be a great daughter. Women will be praised for being flexible, however will be questioned if they’re not. They will be admired for sacrificing however will be called selfish if they’re looking out for themselves. They will be celebrated for their achievements until they start challenging the expectations set for their gender.

When Independent Women Cause Family Issues

Independent women are often praised in Indian society, however it’s hard to accept them within the family. When a daughter moves to another city for work they will be asked who will look after their parents. If they want to go to further education they’ll be told not to delay marriage. If they decline marriage proposals they’ll be accused of being too much and if they chose their own partner they’ll be told they no longer trust their parents.

When comparing this to sons, you’ll often see they’re praised for being ambitious when they move abroad for better opportunities. However if a daughter makes the same decision, they’ll be reminded of their obligation to their parents, husband, family, and “what society would think”. If a son gets married later they’ll be seen as career orientated, however if a daughter does the same they’ll often be questioned about their age, fertility, sanctity, virginity, and future. Their ambition will be seen differently depending on who says it.

This creates normalisation of gender expectations. You don’t need to tell a daughter that she doesn’t have freedom, you just need to have constant conversations, comparisons with other family members, comments from relatives and remind them with emotion. Eventually they’ll feel like they don’t have the freedom to make their own decisions.

Why Marriage is Still Seen as a Daughter’s Obligation

One of the largest expectations that Indian families place on women is to get married. Even if a daughter has spent years studying, becoming financially independent and creating a future for herself, once relatives start asking about marriage it will suddenly become less important. At 20 they’ll be told they have time, at 23 they’ll start receiving suggestions and at 25/27 they’ll start having family conversations about being married off.

They’re rarely asked if they’re ready, instead they’re often asked if they’re getting too old. Sometimes an unmarried daughter is seen as incomplete. Parents can’t feel completely happy until they’ve sorted their marriage. Their preferences, career and emotions will become less important, and they’ll be pressured to marry due to societal pressures. If they want to choose their own partner they’ll be accused of not listening to their parents and if they want to delay marriage they’ll be told they’re causing issues.

Getting married isn’t a test they need to pass to prove they’re a good daughter. Simply getting married at 24 doesn’t make you a better daughter than someone who chooses to get married at 32 or not at all. A meaningful marriage comes from wanting to, compatibility and mutual respect. But will society understand this? No. 

People claiming freedom of choice and privileges of daughters often forget that this is something only upper class women have. In India and the world, even today the reality has not changed. Girls in schools are told they are “blessed” to be “allowed” to study; women in colleges are told they are “given” the freedom to complete their education; women doing jobs before marriage are told they are “lucky” to have open minded family. And who says it? The society and their own family. 

Unspoken Emotional Obligations

One of the least talked about expectations of daughters is the emotional obligation they have within their family. They’re expected to remember birthdays, notice when their mother is upset, worry about their fathers health, keep relationships with family members and ensure there isn’t any conflict within the family. Often they become the go-to person for everything as they’re expected to understand, be flexible and solve issues.

Despite possibly having their own stress, disappointment and emotional exhaustion they’ll feel the need to ensure everyone in the family is doing well. They might hide their issues so they don’t worry their parents, delay difficult conversations as the family are already going through something and apologise for feeling frustrated as they’ve been taught a good daughter should understand everything.

Eventually this becomes normalised and nobody will realise it’s a chore. Instead they’ll just say it’s part of their nature, how they were brought up or that they love their family. However love shouldn’t mean they have to be available for everyone and not have the chance to show their needs.

Do Parents Have the Right to Decide a Daughter’s Future Due to their Sacrifices?

Parents make huge sacrifices to raise their children. They put their time, money and effort into ensuring they have an education, security and opportunities. Many parents give their children a better life than they had. This deserves to be thanked, respected and appreciated.

However just because they’ve given so much doesn’t mean they should expect their daughter to obey them for the rest of their life. Raising a child is a responsibility and an act of love, it doesn’t mean they own their decisions. A daughter can appreciate everything their parents have done without agreeing to their decisions. They can listen to their advice without giving up their right to chose who they marry, where they work and what kind of life they want.

There’s a big difference between involving parents in life decisions and letting them decide. A healthy relationship means there will be conversations, disagreements and individual decisions. Love shouldn’t be conditional on them obeying. Parents deserve to be respected, however daughters deserve to be treated as adults with their own identity, ambitions and understanding of what makes them happy.

Can a Woman Be a Great Daughter Without Sacrificing Her Dreams?

No. at least not until the definition of a great daughter changes. 

A great daughter will look after her parents, provide them with financial or emotional support, respect their opinions and be there for them in tough times. They may chose to live close, involve them in marriage decisions or listen to their advice; however this shouldn’t be a test to prove how much they love them.

They can have a career in another city and still be a loving daughter. They can decline marriage proposals and still respect their parents. They can chose to get married later, further their education, start a business or make decisions their family don’t immediately understand. Being independent doesn’t mean they don’t love their family and disagreeing doesn’t mean they’re disrespectful.

Perhaps we should stop seeing daughters for how many sacrifices they make. Women shouldn’t have to sacrifice their ambitions to prove they remember their family. They shouldn’t have to get married to prove they respect their parents and shouldn’t have to always seek approval for their decisions because their loved ones have different expectations.

A great daughter, as per society, is always someone who agrees with everything. But the harsh truth is that sometimes great daughters are those who are brave enough to disagree honestly whilst still loving their family. And this is something the society never sees. 

The Sad Truth About Being Everyone’s Pride

There are daughters who do everything their family hoped they would. They work hard, have good jobs, support their parents, get married at the right time and continue to meet their families obligations. There are also daughters who quietly give up opportunities to avoid conflict within their family. They may decline jobs in another city, give up further education or agree to marriages they’re unsure about as they don’t want to disappoint their parents.

Not all sacrifices will cause regret and not all women will be unhappy with choosing family over their ambitions. It’s a proud decision to choose to look after the people they love. However there’s a difference between making a choice and having no good options. A sacrifice made willingly can be a sign of love however a sacrifice requested to prove love can cause resentment throughout their life.

The saddest thing is many women never talk about the life they could have had. They learn to call their sacrifices, maturity, their silence, respect and their unfulfilled ambitions part of growing up. They become everyone’s pride however secretly wonder if they ever became someone they were proud of.

A daughter shouldn’t have to chose between being a good member of their family and becoming the woman they want to be. They should be able to love their parents without losing control over their future and respect tradition without being trapped by it.

The real issue isn’t whether a great woman can be a great daughter but why society makes it seem like they can’t. A daughter is a person and a woman is an individual. If their family can only love the version of them that obeys, is flexible and sacrifices then maybe we should reconsider what we’re calling love.

A daughter shouldn’t have to be less of a woman to be a great daughter. We, as a society, must understand that.

Miss Kanishka

Kanishka is a writer and acclaimed poetess from Jabalpur who gives words to things people often overlook. She writes opinion articles and content to create an impact and make people think.

She has been featured in several national and international magazines and anthologies, and holds two national records — one for the longest reverse poem and another for compiling an all-female anthology.

Add comment