Parenting is a deeply personal journey, shaped by culture, environment, and personal values. For Kristen Fischer, an American mother of three, that journey has led her to India—a country she now calls home. Having moved with her family in 2021, Fischer believes that raising her children in India offers them a richer, more fulfilling upbringing than they would have had in the United States.
Her perspective, shared in a now-viral Instagram video, has sparked widespread conversation. With her child walking along an Indian street in the background, Fischer detailed why she believes India provides a better environment for her children’s development. Her reasons, outlined in her post, offer a thought-provoking take on cross-cultural parenting.
A Childhood Rooted in Diversity and Resilience
Fischer emphasizes the cultural depth and diversity that India offers. Unlike the relatively homogenous cultural landscape of many American suburbs, she believes India’s multilingual, multiethnic society will give her children a more profound understanding of different traditions, languages, and worldviews.
"Living in India will expose my children to a rich diversity of cultures, languages, and customs," she wrote. "This aids them in gaining a deep understanding and appreciation of other cultures, promoting open-mindedness and adaptability."
Language, too, plays a key role in her decision. In a multilingual country like India, Fischer’s children have the opportunity to learn Hindi and other regional languages, in addition to English. She believes this will not only enhance their cognitive abilities but also open doors for their future.
Beyond language and culture, Fischer sees India as a place where her children will develop a broader worldview. Being surrounded by diverse economic and social conditions, they will gain a heightened sense of global awareness—something she feels they might not have been exposed to in the U.S.
Building Emotional Intelligence and Stronger Family Bonds
Another factor influencing Fischer’s decision is the strong emphasis on family in Indian society. Unlike the more individualistic culture of the U.S., where children often move out early to pursue independence, she appreciates the tight-knit family values she sees in India.
"Close relationships and extensive family networks are emphasized in many Indian families," she noted. "This gives my children a feeling of belonging, emotional support, and stronger family ties."
Additionally, she believes the challenges of adapting to life in India—be it adjusting to a different education system or learning new social norms—will make her children more resilient and emotionally intelligent. Navigating unfamiliar environments, she argues, will prepare them for the uncertainties of life in a way that a more predictable childhood in the U.S. might not.
Sparking Debate: A Bold Choice or a Risky Experiment?
Fischer’s views have resonated with many, with several social media users praising her for embracing a different culture. One commenter wrote, "Your children are very fortunate to be raised in Indian culture." Another added, "What impresses me most is your willingness to learn and appreciate diversity."
However, not everyone agrees with her perspective. Some users pointed out the irony of her decision, given that many Indian families aspire to move to the U.S. for better opportunities. One comment read, "When Indians are emigrating to the U.S., it's interesting to see someone choose the opposite path and fully commit to it."
Others questioned how her children might adjust in the long run. "Will they experience cultural shock if they move back to the U.S. someday?" one user asked. "They might end up being foreigners in both places—where they live and where they’re from."
A Personal Choice in an Ever-Globalizing World
Ultimately, Fischer’s decision to raise her children in India reflects a larger conversation about global parenting and the shifting perceptions of East vs. West. In a world where borders are increasingly blurred, her story challenges the conventional wisdom that raising children in the U.S. is inherently "better."
For Fischer, India isn’t just where she lives—it’s where she believes her children will thrive. Whether one agrees with her perspective or not, her journey serves as a reminder that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to parenting. Sometimes, the best choices for our children lie beyond the familiar comforts of home.